Homeless people recruited for election raffle scheme, denied pay by organizers

Residents at the Bethesda Mission homeless shelter say they were recruited to promote a raffle outside of polling stations today.

The offer was enticing — $10 an hour for easy work.

On election day, men eager to earn money were shuttled to polling locations across the city, where they were told to hand voters raffle tickets as they entered the polls. Standing in rain that turned to sleet and snow, the men followed all the instructions given to them by their bosses, including the request that they not promote any one candidate.

But then they were told to collect their earnings at 8:00 p.m. at 308 N. 2nd Street – the campaign headquarters of Gloria Martin-Roberts, a write-in candidate for Harrisburg mayor.

Six men enrolled in the long-term recovery program at Bethesda Mission—five of whom were interviewed on the condition that TheBurg not name them in this article—say that they are being denied the money they were offered to distribute raffle tickets outside of polling places on election day. The tickets were accompanied by a flier advertising a chance to win a free iPhone X.

Dauphin County judge Scott Evans issued an injunction against the tickets and fliers today, outlawing their distribution during the county’s investigation. The injunction ordered sheriffs to report to polling places, seize the materials, and get the names and photographs of people proffering them.

The Bethesda Mission residents said that they were questioned and photographed by sheriffs, who told them that they hoped they would get the pay they were promised. The residents also confirmed that they were instructed to report to 308 N. 2nd street at 8 p.m. this evening to collect their earnings for the day — $110 in cash for 11 hours of work.

Now, they’re allegedly being told by the raffle organizers that they won’t receive payment until the county concludes its investigation into the scheme.

“We’re just trying to get paid,” one of the men said. “We stood outside all day and I want my money.”

At 8 p.m., the 2nd street office was darkened and locked, but a group of about 10 people waited outside to collect their money. The men from Bethesda Mission, who represented only a portion of the people who were recruited for the scheme, said they did not plan on going to the office.

Many Harrisburg residents expected today’s general election to be an uneventful affair. When men appeared outside of polling stations and gave voters raffle tickets and fliers, nobody knew what to think—but everyone agreed it was strange.

“I’ve never seen anything like this,” said city solicitor Neil Grover, who reviewed one of the fliers at the 11th ward polls, hosted inside the Neighborhood Center on 3rd Street, Tuesday evening.

Shamaine Daniels, a Harrisburg councilwoman who campaigned for Judge Lori Serratelli at the Neighborhood Center, didn’t know what to make of the raffle scheme.

“Usually, my antenna goes up when there’s a quid pro quo violation,” said Daniels, who is also attorney.

The legal term “quid pro quo” refers to a transactional exchange between two parties.

“But this was just so strange, I didn’t know what to think,” Daniels said.

When county officials arrived and issued the injunction against the raffle, people at the polls worried that the men handing out tickets were vulnerable.

“That’s what worried me, that innocent people would be in trouble,” said Sherry Summerfield, a Republican Party poll watcher at the Neighborhood Center. “They clearly had no idea what they were doing.”

Indeed, some of the men at Bethesda Mission did not know who Gloria Martin-Roberts was. They were told that the raffle tickets were meant to incentivize voting and were instructed to not promote any one candidate.

“They told us there was nothing wrong with it,” one man said about the raffle scheme.

They identified at least two people by photo who helped organize the raffle. They said that Kyle Myers, who appears in a Facebook video promoting the raffle, drove them to polling places. Other men identified Jennie Jenkins, a former mayoral candidate, as someone who brought them pizza and gave them instructions for engaging voters.

Myers did not respond to a message sent to his Facebook account on Tuesday night, and Jenkins declined to comment by phone.

Bill Christian, director of the men’s shelter at Bethesda Mission, said that candidates and political parties often recruit at the Mission during elections, offering men money to distribute campaign literature.

Christian did not know that the men were being roped into a legally murky scheme or that they’d be asked to share only limited information with voters.

“I would have never let them go if I’d known that,” Christian said.

The Mission residents said that they get few chances to earn cash and jumped at the opportunity to work the polls. Many of the men are nearing the end of their 12-month recovery program at the shelter, and were hoping to use the money when they leave.

“What everyone should be mad about is that they’re ripping off homeless people,” said one resident.

Another said that he kept his raffle tickets as a form of insurance in case he is denied pay.

“If they don’t pay me I have proof that I worked,” he said.

Attempts to reach Martin-Roberts and her campaign on Tuesday night were unsuccessful.

Continue Reading

Dauphin County Sheriff Visits Martin-Roberts Campaign Office as Raffle Probe Mounts

The downtown Harrisburg building housing the campaign office of Gloria Martin-Roberts.

A raffle scheme offering voters the chance to win a free iPhone X has apparent connections to the Gloria Martin-Roberts mayoral campaign, but it is unclear whether the write-in candidate sanctioned it herself.

Dauphin County Sheriff Nicholas Chimienti Jr. and an investigator went to the Martin-Roberts campaign office on N. 2nd Street at about 4:45 p.m. this afternoon, where they spoke with staffers. At that time, a box with flyers advertising the raffle and flyers proclaiming, “Vote NO Papenfuse; Write in Gloria Martin Roberts,” were in the office, along with reams of blue raffle tickets.

Chimienti would not comment on the investigation as he left the campaign office just after 5 p.m.

Campaign staffers also declined to speak with reporters and became hostile when they tried to take photos inside or outside the office. People who said they were hired by the campaign to distribute flyers (pictured below) and raffle tickets also filed out of the building and declined to comment.

Several Harrisburg voters filed complaints today after receiving raffle tickets from men stationed at the entrances of polling places. At some locations, the tickets were accompanied by flyers advertising a voter turnout initiative offering voters the chance to win prizes if they voted. The raffle offered a free iPhone X, valued at $1,000, to a first-prize winner, $500 cash to a second-place winner, and a $200 Best Buy gift card to a third winner.

Subsequently, early this afternoon, Dauphin County Judge Arthur Evans issued an injunction that all raffle tickets be seized from precincts 4, 5, 10, 11, 12, 13 and 14. He further ordered that all Dauphin County sheriffs visit all polling stations and seize all raffle tickets.

Devar Bailey of Harrisburg said he was stationed at the 10-1 polling location at Woodbine and N. 3rd streets. He got the job after answering a Craigslist ad offering $10 an hour to hand out materials that included pro-Martin-Roberts flyers and raffle tickets.

“A lot of people took it,” he said, adding that he was recruited by a woman he identified as “Jennie Jenkins.”

Jenkins, a former candidate for mayor, refused to be interviewed for this story, saying that all questions should be directed to her attorney.

At the same location, a poll watcher left behind a bag of flyers and raffle tickets, which was later obtained by TheBurg (pictured below).



Bailey said he was instructed to visit the Martin-Roberts headquarters on N. 2nd Street at 8 p.m. to get paid. He said he worked a total of nine hours, until 3 p.m., handing out material.


While Bailey was recruited by a Craigslist ad, other large groups of poll workers were recruited from local shelters, including Bethesda Mission and Downtown Daily Bread, according to sources.

Martin-Roberts lost to Mayor Eric Papenfuse in the May Democratic primary for mayor. She declared just last week that she would mount a write-in campaign for the seat.


This story was updated to include that Jennie Jenkins refused comment.

Continue Reading

Raffle Tickets, Flyers Dent Harrisburg’s Mayoral Election

Campaign signs line the State Street median in Harrisburg.

A Dauphin County judge issued an injunction today to stop the distribution of raffle tickets that appeared to encourage people to vote a certain way in the race for Harrisburg mayor.

People at many city polling stations were found to be handing out raffle tickets, which promised prizes including a new iPhone X (first prize), $500 in cash (second prize) and a $200 Best Buy gift card (third prize).

Winners, the ticket said, would be announced on a Facebook page called Harrisburg Mayoral Election 2017.

“The Court finds that the raffle ticket is also promoting of a particular race and suggestive of balloting,” according to the court order.

Judge Arthur Evans ordered that all raffle tickets be seized from precincts 4, 5, 10, 11, 12, 13 and 14. He further ordered that all Dauphin County sheriffs visit all polling stations and seize all raffle tickets.

To promote the raffle, fliers were also handed out saying, “NO Papenfuse. Vote Write-in. Gloria Martin-Roberts. Stand for Equality.”

Just a few days ago, Martin-Roberts announced on Facebook that she would mount a late write-in campaign for mayor. She lost in the Democratic primary in May to incumbent Mayor Eric Papenfuse. Papenfuse also gained more write-in votes than Martin-Roberts from Republican voters, so also appears on the Republican ballot for mayor.

Polls close at 8 p.m.

Continue Reading

Shelter on South Street: Local soup kitchen will offer beds to homeless this winter

Downtown Daily Bread will open an overnight shelter at its location at 234 South Street.

Following a change in policy at Harrisburg’s largest rescue mission, a downtown soup kitchen plans to open an emergency overnight shelter for 30 homeless men.

Downtown Daily Bread, a soup kitchen and daytime shelter operated by Pine Street Presbyterian Church on N. 3rd Street, got approval from the city Planning Commission to operate a 30-bed men’s shelter from Dec. 1 to March 31 at its facility at 234 South St.

The organization expects to get a stamp of approval from the Zoning Hearing Board later this month, the final step in the permitting process, according to Anne Guenin, director of Downtown Daily Bread.

Downtown Daily Bread currently runs a daily drop-in shelter where people can nap, shower, receive meals and pick up mail. It serves between 70 and 90 people on an average day, Guenin said.

The night shelter will be in the same facility as the daytime shelter, which operates from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. The nighttime shelter will open at 7:30 p.m., giving crews time to clean and convert the gymnasium to a dormitory with cots, and close at 6 a.m.

Guenin said that the shelter originated in response to an operational change at Bethesda Mission, which this year decided to open its emergency shelter only in extreme weather conditions. Bill Christian, director of the Bethesda Mission men’s shelter, said that his organization made this choice to better serve its neediest clients.

Christian and Guenin both explained that some patrons of overnight shelters have sources of income, but surrender their housing arrangements when winter shelters open.

Bethesda Mission served as many as 160 people every night in its shelter last year, far exceeding its 120-person capacity, Christian said. He estimated that a third of that population had sources of income and could afford housing.

But since Bethesda Mission ran a shelter from Dec. 1 to March 31, some low-income clients knew they could rely on the shelter for a place to stay and save money, Christian said.

This year, the emergency shelter at Bethesda Mission will provide 120 beds when temperatures dip below 20 degrees or when there is freezing precipitation. It will continue to operate its year-round temporary shelter, which offers initial stays of 20 days along with food, clothing and counseling services.

When the emergency shelter opened on a weather-dependent basis in the past, it never had as many clients as it did last year, Christian said.

“If a person knows that certain weather conditions have to be met, he won’t give up his boarding room,” Christian said.

Guenin and Christian and their staffs have told patrons about the changes and encouraged them to retain their housing if they have it.

Between this outreach effort and the 30 additional beds opening at Downtown Daily Bread, they hope—but are not certain—that anyone seeking shelter in Harrisburg will find it. Both said that some homeless people do not seek shelter, possibly because of zero-tolerance drug and alcohol policies in effect at most missions.

While both the Downtown Daily Bread and Bethesda Mission shelters only serve men, the YWCA of Harrisburg operates a shelter for women and children at 1101 Market St. Guenin said that most of the homeless population Daily Bread serves is male.

To be eligible for a bed at Downtown Daily Bread’s overnight shelter, a patron must not have a source of income. Shelter staff will try to determine a patron’s eligibility during the nightly intake period, but Guenin expects that during their daytime services will help with recruitment.

“We’re starting that process now and already making a roster of who might be eligible,” she said.

Equipment and operating costs for the four-month shelter period will amount to roughly $50,000, Guenin said. Downtown Daily Bread plans to hire four additional staff to manage the shelter and provide overnight security, and will also buy a new washer and dryer to launder bed linens.

To learn about Downtown Daily Bread or donate to the shelter fund, visit https://pinestreet.org/ministries/downtown-daily-bread.

Continue Reading

City announces date, route of 2017 holiday parade

Food trucks, music and inflatable gingerbread men are all on the agenda for this year’s holiday parade, which will take place on Saturday, Nov. 18 in downtown Harrisburg.

Mayor Eric Papenfuse announced details of the parade at a press conference this morning, which took place in city hall and featured a guest appearance by Santa Claus.

The parade will begin at noon and continue until 3 p.m., rain or shine. It will begin on Market Street then travel up 2nd Street and on to North Street. The route will continue on Front Street and conclude on City Island.

The parade will feature giant inflatables from Big Events, an international provider of parade balloons. Local marching bands and dance teams will provide entertainment, and hungry parade-goers can avail themselves of food trucks parked on Market Street.

The afternoon’s festivities will be broadcast on Channel 20. Residents who don’t want to brave the cold can join the after-party at Strawberry Square beginning at 3 p.m.

There, they can visit with Santa, enjoy holiday cookies and hot chocolate, and watch encore performances from the step teams, drill teams and marching bands that participated in the parade. PSECU will offer prize money to the best teams as picked by a panel of judges.

Visitors who drive to watch the parade can get four hours of free parking by using the promo code LUVHBG on the ParkMobile app. The Market Square garage will also offer a $10 flat rate special for parade day.

Continue Reading

3rd and Long: Yearlong 3rd Street improvement project set to start.

Patched, worn and pot-holed 3rd Street in Harrisburg is ready for its makeover.

People of Harrisburg—the day is almost here.

The long-promised repaving of 3rd Street is set to begin, as the city has scheduled a groundbreaking on Thursday at N. 3rd and Sayford streets to mark the start of the project.

The project will include substantial work, including milling and paving, on the following sections of the street:

  • Chestnut Street to State Street
  • Forster Street to Muench Street
  • Maclay Street to Seneca Street

Most of the initial work will not involve actual paving, but associated improvements, such as ADA-compliant curb ramps, traffic signal upgrades and new street trees and pits.

Street repaving will hold off until next spring as asphalt cannot be laid down in cold weather. The city expects the project to run through October 2018.

Initially, the repaving was supposed to have taken place this year, but was delayed because the city needed to coordinate with Capital Region Water (CRW), which is using the opportunity to install new drainage pipes.

Harrisburg has contracted with Elizabethtown-based Doug Lamb Construction Inc. for the $5.5 million project, a cost split between the city and CRW. The city is paying an estimated $3.5 million, with CRW footing the remaining $2 million.

The project is funded by a $6 million grant from Impact Harrisburg, a nonprofit set up as part of the city’s financial recovery plan.

The city says that parking on the street may be affected. It will post “no parking” signs 24 hours before work is set to begin on a section of street.

Continue Reading

TheBurg Podcast, Nov. 3, 2017

TheBurg Podcast returns after a long hiatus!

This week, Editor in Chief Larry Binda and City Reporter Lizzy Hardison discuss why anti-abortion advocates are suing the city, the proposed changes to 2nd Street, and the revivification of Harrisburg’s mysterious comprehensive plan. Plus, Lizzy breaks down the details of a proposed amendment to the state constitution, which will be on the ballot in Tuesday’s elections. Listen to the end to hear your hosts’ picks for “The Most Harrisburg Thing This Week.” (Hint: they mostly have to do with pasta.)

Stream this week’s episode on SoundCloud. You can also download it in iTunes, or on the Apple and Android podcast apps.

Find the stories referenced in this week’s podcast: 

Abortion foes challenge Harrisburg protest buffer in court.

2-Way 2nd: Council action brings major road change nearer.

Plan of Action: Progress finally made on Harrisburg’s comprehensive plan.

Property tax amendment mired in uncertainty ahead of November election.

I’ve Got a Secret: Some of the best places in Harrisburg are worth searching out.

Curious how Second Street became the mimi-highway that it is today? Read this 2013 feature from former Burg city reporter Paul Barker.

Second Thoughts: Decades ago, Harrisburg’s leaders quickly turned 2nd Street into an urban highway. Some people now think they made a big mistake.

Continue Reading

Plan of Action: Progress finally made on Harrisburg’s comprehensive plan.

Aerial view of Harrisburg. Photo by Dani Fresh

Harrisburg’s long-delayed comprehensive plan appears to be back on track, as the city’s Planning Commission last night agreed on a draft plan and set forth a path for final approval.

The commission unanimously opted for a draft submitted by the Office for Planning and Architecture, a city-based firm headed by urban design consultant Bret Peters.

In May 2015, the city hired Peters for $200,000 to create a comprehensive plan, which cities use as frameworks to guide policy, ranging widely to include everything from land use to recreation. Plans typically have a shelf life of only 10 to 15 years, though Harrisburg’s had not been redrafted in some four decades.

Originally, the city expected its plan to be finished in about 10 months. However, a dispute with Peters over the editing process, communication and, especially, pay, led to a long delay.

At one point earlier this year, the city and Peters parted company after Peters demanded more money to complete the project.

That holdup ended last evening with the commission’s decision to go with Peters’ draft. Commission members said they would make the draft public both online and in hard copy by Nov. 15, with a public hearing slated for Jan. 10.

Following the hearing, the commission may make additional changes based on public input. It then must approve the final draft before submitting it to City Council for its approval.

Several city officials attended the commission meeting and seemed relieved that the process had new momentum.

“That’s why I’m here tonight,” said council President Wanda Williams. “They want to know, ‘Where is the comprehensive plan?’ Thank you for finally moving ahead.”

Mayor Eric Papenfuse said the city has not paid Peters more money than the contract allows and would not do so. Nonetheless, he echoed Williams’ sentiments.

“At least we’re moving the process forward,” he said. “So, it’s positive in that way.”

Continue Reading

Weekend Roundup with Sara Bozich

Happy Weekend!

Please excuse the abbreviated Weekend Roundup. See the reason why:

https://www.sarabozich.com/2017/11/hey-i-had-a-baby/

What are you doing this weekend?

(more…)

Continue Reading

Abortion foes challenge Harrisburg protest buffer in court

Abortion opponents seek an injunction against a Harrisburg city ordinance, saying it limits their ability to offer anti-abortion literature and counseling to women at the 2nd St. Planned Parenthood.

Becky Biter says that the Holy Spirit “lit a fire in her soul” at a religious retreat in 2014, and she has advocated for the end of legal abortion ever since.

Now, Biter and another abortion opponent are taking legal action against Harrisburg for allegedly limiting their free speech rights. They seek an injunction against the city’s “buffer ordinance,” which, since 2012, has outlawed people from protesting, picketing or congregating within 20 feet of health clinic entrances.

Mayor Eric Papenfuse said he stands by the ordinance as a fair protection of both free speech and the right to medical care. The plaintiffs claim that it limits their ability to engage in a form of advocacy called “sidewalk counseling” outside of the 2nd Street Planned Parenthood. That facility is currently the only abortion provider in Harrisburg.

Both sides made their cases yesterday and today before the Hon. Sylvia Rambo, U.S. District Court judge for the Middle District of Pennsylvania at the federal courthouse on Market Street. Liberty Counsel, a Florida-based advocacy group, represented Biter, of Fayetville, and co-plaintiff Colleen Riley, of Lebanon pro bono (at no cost.)

The original injunction also listed Lancaster resident Rosalie Gross as a plaintiff. She was dropped from the case after video footage showed her heckling Planned Parenthood patients, Papenfuse said.

The trial concluded this afternoon with testimony from both remaining plaintiffs. Biter recounted how she was driven to an abortion clinic at age 15 by an abusive boyfriend, who forced her to terminate her unplanned pregnancy.

She said her regret over the abortion led to years of depression and post-traumatic stress disorder, and she claimed that she now wants to spare other women from the same distress.

Claims about the psychological harms of abortion have proliferated since the Supreme Court heard Roe v. Wade in 1973. A peer-reviewed paper published in the American Psychological Journal in 2009, which included a comprehensive review of extant literature on the topic, found that the majority of women who terminate pregnancies do not experience mental health problems.

“Although we conclude that most adult women do not have mental health problems following an abortion of an unwanted pregnancy, we do not mean to imply that no women experience such problems. Some women do,” the researchers wrote.

But they said that those mental health problems could stem from ambivalence toward the abortion or fear of social stigmatization, as well as co-occurring conditions such as unhealthy relationships or economic insecurity.

Pro-life advocates nonetheless point to these perceived psychological harms to dissuade women from seeking abortions. Biter and Riley said that offering “sidewalk counseling” outside of abortion clinics helps them protect women from post-abortion distress.

Before the court, both women insisted that sidewalk counseling is different from protesting. A Liberty Counsel attorney objected when Frank Lavery, a lawyer representing the city, referred to them as “protesters.” Biter and Riley said that they never heckle patrons, raise their voices, or display posters with graphic images.

Instead, they claimed they politely approach women as they walk towards abortion clinics to offer them prayer and literature. Their methods are less effective, they said, when they cannot enter the 20-foot buffer zone near the Planned Parenthood entrance.

“Our goal is to show women they’re not alone,” Biter said on the stand. “The best way is to get close to a woman, hug her, lead her away from the abortion facility, and sit her down in a safe place to show her someone cares.”

During cross examination, Lavery pointed that even though the plaintiffs might be peaceful activists, voiding the buffer ordinance would also empower more confrontational protesters.

If Rambo rules in favor of the plaintiffs, she will issue a preliminary injunction against the city’s ordinance, which would void it during an inevitable appeals process. The defense could then file a motion to make the injunction permanent.

The injunction against Harrisburg was filed in March 2016. City Solicitor Neil Grover estimates that the city has spent more than $60,000 litigating the case since then, mostly on outside counsel.

But there’s even more at stake. If the plaintiffs prevail, Harrisburg will have to reimburse Liberty Counsel for their legal fees in accordance with a Civil Rights Act statute.

Both sides will rest until the court stenographer completes the 500-page transcript of the proceedings. Grover said that could take until January.

After attorneys receive the transcript, they will have 20 days to review it and submit final arguments to Rambo. The judge has no time constraint on her final ruling.

Continue Reading