
Al Pera, Sue Pera, Alexander Shover, Caleb Watters, Justine Welling
More than three decades in the food business is no small feat.
That’s why Sue and Al Pera, who led Cornerstone Coffeehouse in Camp Hill for most of its history, were particular about who would run their café and community gathering spot upon their retirement.
“There’s always pressure to not screw it up,” says Caleb Watters, who finalized the deal to purchase the business in early 2025 with his wife, Alexandra Shover.
Still, Watters and his team plan to keep the essence of Cornerstone as is, hopefully satisfying the community that surrounds it.
“People here were very invested because they’ve been coming here for 30 years,” Watters said. “The first couple of months has proven that we’re not looking to do some monumental change, so I think that’s calmed a lot of nerves.”
Watters himself is not a restaurateur, but an operator. He also owns Valley Bistro in Enola and The Hershey Pantry in Hershey.
“I am buying a system,” he said. “I’m going to work within that system, and then we’ll improve it over time.”
Right now, that looks like rearranging equipment and processes in the back of house and investing in better equipment. The only thing guests will see from these changes, he said, is they’ll get their food and drink faster. Once all that is set up, he’ll move to the front of house, perhaps optimizing seating to fit more people (because, on a busy day, the place is packed).
Cornerstone is known for its espresso menu, breakfast sandwiches (like the bacon, egg, cheddar and avocado) and cooking classes in the back room. Customers also have the chance to browse art and goods from local creators amid a fun, laid-back vibe.
Then there are the intangible offerings, Watters said,
“If you’ve been in coffeehouses, there’s a buzz in certain places,” he said. “We’re always going to foster that.”
Full Circle
Shover said that they’re proud to continue the coffeehouse’s legacy, which she recognizes has become an integral part of the Camp Hill community.
“We even have a couple helpers who will be joining the crew when they are old enough,” said Shover, referring to her sons, ages 4 and 7.
Watters himself is from St. Louis. More recently, the family lived in Youngstown, Ohio. There, Watters worked as a Dunkin’ franchisee, with 12 locations under his charge, all of which had a full-production kitchen and 24-hour-a-day operations. His operations manager and self-proclaimed “right-hand person,” Justine Welling, helped him manage everything.
When Watters had an opportunity to get bought out of the Dunkin’ business, he took it.
“Sometimes, you’ve got to know when to exit,” he said.
Once he decided to move to Pennsylvania and start an independent restaurant venture, he offered Welling the chance to come with them. She took it and currently helps operate the ins and outs of his three businesses.
But Watters is heavily involved, too—though in his own way.
“There’s a lot of things I try not to know,” he said, leaving some of the day-to-day grind for Welling. “But I’m here every day.”
Watters has come a long way since his first job out of college working on the corporate side of Dippin’ Dots.
“You’re out of college, you don’t know what you’re going to do, here’s the opportunity, and it just snowballs,” he said. “Then you realize you’re good at it. If I was smart, I would have just left the industry after Dunkin’. But I like it, there’s money, and you learn how to cope with the stress.”
Expanding Cornerstone down the line isn’t necessarily out of the question, but that’s not on the table right now. For the moment, Watters, Shover, Welling and the rest of their team—including general manager Nicole Miller, who has been in her post for about 14 years—are just looking to make the café even better.
While Watters isn’t from the area, Shover is. Interestingly, she grew up just across the street from where they now live in Camp Hill—near their new coffeehouse.
“My friends and I used to walk to the Cornerstone for lunch,” she said. “To now own it feels like a full-circle moment.”
Cornerstone Coffeehouse is located at 2133 Market St., Camp Hill. For more information, visit www.thecornerstonecoffeehouse.com.
If you like what we do, please support our work. Become a Friend of TheBurg!



Bright, friendly, futuristic.
Many years ago, when our sons were young, we took them on lots of “day trips.”

