Cats saunter about as if they own the place, and in fact, they kind of do.
At Forever Love Rescue’s Kitty Corner in downtown Gettysburg, as many as 60 cats live in a home-like atmosphere, many of them cage-free, wandering the premises, jumping on counters, lounging in windows, and playing with a myriad of toys.
Forever Love Rescue started in 2013 as Vega’s New Leash on Life Pet Rescue after Stephanie and Jeffrey Baum made a trip to a shelter in Bamberg, S.C., to replace a pet dog that had died.
“On the way home, my wheels were turning,” Stephanie Baum said. “I wanted to start a program to bring dogs up north to try to find them homes.”
Baum brought more than 200 dogs through her home in the next three to four years, fostering them until she found them homes. While she still has a passion for dogs, she realized that south-central Pennsylvania didn’t really have a dog problem, but that cats needed saving. So, she branched out in 2014
“We realized that lots and lots of cats needed us,” Baum said. “It was much more feasible to house cats than a dog kennel.”
In 2015, the name of the rescue changed to Forever Love Rescue with a cat added to the logo, and, by October of that year, the Kitty Corner had opened in downtown Gettysburg.
As active participants in the trap, neuter, release (TNR) program, Kitty Corner began to focus almost exclusively on the overpopulation of cats in the community and expanded into the even larger Queen Street space in 2019.

Lovey Dovey
Every cat that comes to Kitty Corner goes through a quarantine period in a cage in a special room. Cats are not released to the general population until they are spayed or neutered and vaccinated, as well as micro-chipped.
The average cost to the shelter to prepare a cat for adoption is about $150. Meanwhile, Forever Love Rescue charges $60 for adoption of adult cats and $100 for kittens.
Some cats get adopted quickly, but others are long-term residents. That’s because Forever Love Rescue is a no-kill shelter.
“Once they enter our program, they stay with us until they get adopted,” Baum said.
Last year, the shelter took in 350 cats, 296 of which were adopted. Sometimes, foster families end up adopting cats, too.
Candi Clark adopted twin kittens right before a snowstorm in December 2020. She had intended on only one cat to replace hers that had recently died. When she visited, a kitten came over and climbed into her lap and fell asleep. Although it had picked her, she first went home to discuss it with her husband.
When she came back, a kitten came and put his paws on her shoulder and “was all lovey dovey.” Clark thought it was the kitten she had held previously, but it turned out to be its brother.
“I have to get both of them,” she said of the gray pair already named Grayden and Grady. “They had a sister named Grace, already gone, thank God, or I would have ended up with her, too.”
She believes in the mission so much that she does her part to support them, too. She crochets kitty beds that are given away at The Lucky Paw in Gettysburg in exchange for donations to the shelter.
“The experience with Forever Love has been great,” Clark said. “They are terrific about the whole adoption process.”
Filling the Void
Kitty Corner has just one full-time employee, Maddie Dzbynski, who was a volunteer before taking the job three years ago. She keeps the records, helps with adoptions, and manages schedules, donations and vet visits, among other duties
Otherwise, Kitty Corner relies exclusively on volunteers and foster families.
About four dozen volunteers not only help with cleaning and care, they also bake to raise money. Valentine’s Day and Mother’s Day are two of the biggest bake sale fundraisers, Clark said.
The rescue is a nonprofit that does not receive any large grants or government funding.
All bills are paid through donations. Kitty Corner also accepts donations of food, medicine, toys and other needed items.
“Everything we do is our generous community allowing it to happen,” Baum said.
When April Gerbrick retired as the supervising hygienist for a large dental practice in 2016, she needed something to fill the void. Since, she has volunteered five or six hours a week, helping with inventory and with adoptive family applications.
“It makes me feel good every day,” Gerbrick said. “We’ve seen some really sad cases come in here, but we have also seen some success stories.”
She added that she’s become passionate about TNR.
“All volunteers are pretty involved in trying to get the word out to the community,” she said. “A lot of people don’t understand about spaying and neutering and what can happen to kittens if they’re not taken care of.”
Baum said that, in helping with the TNR program, the shelter assists colonies of cats living outdoors with caretakers who feed them. They help caretakers catch the cats, get them fixed, and return them to their colonies so they aren’t producing kittens.
“Last year, we fixed 720 outdoor cats,” she said. “Our goal is to fix as many of them as we can so we don’t get all the calls in the spring that there are kittens that need rescued.”
Between Baum’s dedication, the work of fosters and volunteers and adoptive families, Forever Love Rescue is helping to fix a public problem.
“Our goal every day is just to do as much as we can, and we are very proud of everything we do,” Baum said.
Forever Love Rescue’s Kitty Corner is located at 39 Queen St., Gettysburg. For more information, visit www.foreverloverescue.com, follow them on Facebook at Forever Love Rescue or Instagram @Kittycornergettysburg.
If you like what we do, please support our work. Become a Friend of TheBurg!