
Dauphin County Courthouse
A former Harrisburg judge found guilty of attempted murder has been sentenced to over a decade in prison.
On Wednesday in the Dauphin County Courthouse, Sonya McKnight, 57, was sentenced to 13.5 to 30 years in jail for shooting her ex-boyfriend Michael McCoy in the head while he slept.
At the sentencing McKnight also resigned her position as a Magisterial District Judge in Harrisburg and was barred from serving in the future. McKnight had been suspended from her role since November 2023 based on misconduct allegations from the Judicial Conduct Board of Pennsylvania.
Out-of-county Judge Howard Knisley, of Lancaster County, imposed the prison sentence over a month after McKnight was declared guilty on one count of attempted first-degree murder and one count of aggravated assault by a jury. McKnight was originally arrested in February 2024 in relation to the shooting.
“It’s the sentence we were basically hoping for and asked for,” Cumberland County District Attorney Sean McCormack told TheBurg. McCormack’s office took on prosecution of the case, due to McKnight holding a position as judge in Dauphin County.
Before the judge’s decision, McCormack argued that McKnight has shown no remorse for her actions, has permanently disabled McCoy and has tried to direct blame towards others. He said that, during the pre-sentencing investigation, McKnight stated that she believed local officials were conspiring on a way to get her out of her judge seat.
Knisley, upon his sentencing, echoed several of McCormack’s statements.
“The defendant is totally without remorse for her actions,” he said. “These are the actions of a calculating individual.”
Just before that, McKnight herself spoke for the first time during the courtroom hearings, dressed in jail clothes and hands chained, and said that her “character stands firm.”
“I just want you to know who I am, who I truly am. There’s not two sides to me,” she said in response to a claim made by McCormack. “I have not a monstrous side at all.”
Several family members and friends also spoke on McKnight’s behalf, painting a picture of a teen mom who faced challenges in life, but rose to become a judge, woman of faith and respected, well-known member of the community.
“Sacrificing and serving was the theme of her life,” McKnight’s eldest son, who will act as her power of attorney, said. “At the end of the day, I couldn’t ask for a better mother.”
McKnight’s attorney, Cory Leshner, maintained that McKnight was innocent and said that “the appeal process will be ongoing.”
In the end, McKnight was sentenced according to the sentencing guidelines, not receiving a lower sentence within the mitigated range, despite her the statements from her family and friends. Knisley stated that he believed McKnight had a full understanding of her actions and the consequences, is intelligent and has a work history that shows her knowledge of the criminal justice system.
“This is an unbelievable and sad day for all involved,” Knisley said.
The 13.5-year sentence will serve as the minimum amount of time that McKnight will be in prison before she is eligible for parole. Thirty years is the maximum amount of time she can serve. The time McKnight has already spent in prison will count toward her total sentence.
McKnight cried, hugging family and friends following the sentencing.
McCoy attended the hearing, but chose not to speak, leaving it to a few friends and family members to share how the shooting has impacted his life.
“Mike didn’t deserve this,” one woman shared.
McCoy underwent several surgeries following the shooting and remains legally blind in one eye as a result of his injuries.
“She betrayed the community that she served,” McCormack said during the hearing. “She can’t take back the absolute terror that she sent through Mike McCoy’s family.”
Throughout the early April trial, testimony by McCoy and the prosecution maintained that he did not shoot himself, despite insinuations by the defense that he may have. McCoy never said that McKnight shot him, but that he didn’t know because he was asleep when he was shot and blinded when he awoke. However, he did say that he and McKnight were the only ones in his house where he was shot.
In the end, the jury took less than two hours to deliberate and unanimously find McKnight guilty.
If you like what we do, please support our work. Become a Friend of TheBurg!