A heated election, nagging parking problems and lots of bickering—Harrisburg, as usual, didn’t lack for drama in 2015.
Once again, it’s time for my annual Top 10 list of Harrisburg news events. Each January, I revisit and rank the stories that I believe had the greatest impact on the capital city over the prior year.
In some ways, Harrisburg had a good year (continued redevelopment) and in some ways a bad year (stubbornly high crime). All in all, 2015 was a year that started off with great expectations of progress, had plenty of highs and lows and ended up decidedly mixed.
- Kipona Chaos. The last thing that Harrisburg needed was to feed the perception that the city is unsafe—and that’s exactly what it got as scores, hundreds (who really knows?) of youth went on a Labor Day weekend rampage. The trouble began with an argument between two teenagers just as the annual Kipona festival was wrapping up for the night. Soon, crowds of kids descended on the riverfront and, emboldened by their numbers, began roaming through streets in Midtown and Uptown, vandalizing cars (including the police chief’s!) and a convenience store. One teenager accidentally shot himself in the leg. Eventually, arrests were made, but not before the damage had been done both to property and to the city’s always-fragile image.
- Bar Brawl. What responsibility does a business have to its community? I asked that question in a blog post last year after the city tried to shut down several bars it deemed problematic. The 3rd Street Café in Midtown fought back, appealing revocation of its business license to the Dauphin County court. The owner claimed he couldn’t be held responsible for what his patrons did just outside his bar; the city disagreed. At press time, the judge still had not decided whether the bar stays open or closes.
- Front Street Fix. First came the lane closures, then the tree cutting, then—oh boy—the noise. By early summer, Harrisburg was divided in two: those who approved of PennDOT’s redesign of Front Street and those who didn’t. In the end, it wasn’t the commuters, reduced to two lanes, who bore the brunt of the project, but those who lived along the street, shocked to discover that PennDOT could, and did, work all night long. However, due to their sacrifice, Harrisburg now has a smooth, less forbidding road, which, on most days, begs the question—why were there ever three lanes to begin with?
- Nightmare at the Museum. What’s messier than a splatter painting studio? The financial tangle that the Susquehanna Art Museum found itself in just months after opening the doors to its beautiful new facility in Midtown. To sum up: two entities laid claim to one $1.2 million state grant—JEM Group (the project’s general contractor) and Fulton Bank, which wanted to get paid after SAM defaulted on a $3 million loan. The sides chose negotiation over litigation, and, by year-end, an agreement was at hand, which provided some funds to both entities and allowed the museum to stay open.
- Midtown Resurgence. At this time last year, the following places did not exist: The Millworks, Zeroday Brewing, the SAM building, Next Step Performance and both The Kitchen and The Capitol Room at HMAC. They all opened last year, and, in October, WCI Partners began converting the Moose Lodge/Ron Brown complex to mixed-use space, bringing back an entire city block that had been shuttered for a decade. In other words, 2015 was a landmark year for Midtown’s main commercial stretch. Unfortunately, it wasn’t all good news. SAM’s financial troubles clouded the picture, and another big project, GreenWork’s proposed “Education Row,” went nowhere. Will last year’s new projects finally push Midtown past the tipping point, ending its annoying one-step-forward, half-a-step-back routine?
- Parking Redux Redux. When it comes to Harrisburg’s parking system, if it’s not one thing, it’s another. Parking meter revenues topped projections, but nagging enforcement problems and weak garage usage provided far less income than was expected. One bright spot: Mayor Eric Papenfuse’s gamble—which lowered happy hour rates downtown and provided four free hours of parking on Saturday—paid off, so those parker-friendly measures should continue. So, for the third straight year, parking scores a spot on my annual Top 10 list. To steal a quote from the Washington Post’s Chris Cillizza—congrats, or something.
- Papen-fights. City Council, the county commissioners, the Harrisburg Regional Chamber, the Hershey-Harrisburg Regional Visitors Bureau—if there was an entity to tussle with, Mayor Papenfuse tussled. October may have been the low point, with Council President Wanda Williams repeatedly calling him “a liar” followed by public squabbles with both HHRVB and the Chamber/CREDC. By year-end, the mayor and his frenemies had mostly walked back their disputes, agreeing to work towards resolutions or at least a détente.
- Council Shakeup. Eric Papenfuse is not a shy guy (see above). On TheBurg Podcast, he boldly stated that City Council needed new blood and who, in his opinion, should stay and go. He got his way. Following a spirited election, city residents voted in three new council members, substantially changing the tenor of the seven-member body. I rank this story high not because of the 2015 campaign, per se, but because of what it could mean for the city—and the mayor’s legislative priorities—in 2016.
- Harrisburg Less Strong. “Harrisburg Strong” began to show its weak spots as the city’s financial recovery plan failed to deliver expected revenues for a second straight year. In 2015, city revenue was about $6 million less than projected by the Strong Plan. Papenfuse said that the plan’s architects had made overly optimistic projections and that some critical revenue sources, such as from the aforementioned parking, were soft. To fix the structural deficit and deliver an acceptable level of city services, the mayor called for a tripling of the local services tax and greater revenue from commercial sanitation enforcement as part of his 2016 budget.
- Reed Arrested. There was no contest for the year’s No. 1 story, as former Mayor Steve Reed’s arrest was not just Harrisburg news but national news. Love him or hate him, Reed reigned over the city for 28 years, commandeering a comeback built upon a combination of bricks, mortar, debt and delusion. In the end, he was indicted on nearly 500 criminal counts covering various theft, fraud and corruption charges. The sight of agents hauling hundreds of museum-quality Wild West artifacts out of Reed’s poorly maintained Cumberland Street house is one this city will not soon forget.
So, what’s the final verdict on 2015? There were plenty of ups and downs, but, in the end, I think we were marginally better off as a city on Dec. 31 than we were on Jan. 1. Not a lot. Not enough. And probably not as much as I had hoped or expected. But, all in all, we’ve moved forward a few squares.
Lawrance Binda is editor-in-chief of TheBurg.